Intolerance! A Silent Epic Exploring Societal Conflicts and Grand Spectacles?
In the realm of silent cinema, D.W. Griffith’s epic “Intolerance” (1916) stands as a monumental achievement. Released over a century ago, this ambitious film continues to resonate with audiences today for its audacity, scope, and powerful message about humanity’s cyclical struggle with prejudice and intolerance.
Before diving into the depths of “Intolerance,” let’s address the elephant in the room: its reputation. Griffith, while a pioneer in cinematic storytelling, held controversial views that permeated some of his work, notably the infamous “The Birth of a Nation” (1915). “Intolerance” was conceived partly as a response to the criticism he faced for the earlier film’s blatant racism.
However, simply labeling “Intolerance” as Griffith’s attempt at redemption is reductive. The film transcends its creator’s personal complexities and achieves something truly remarkable: a poignant exploration of human conflict across different eras and cultures.
Weaving Tales Across Time
Griffith ingeniously weaves together four seemingly disparate narratives:
-
The Story of Babylon: Set in ancient Babylon, this segment explores the downfall of a great civilization due to the machinations of a power-hungry ruler.
-
The Judea Story: This episode delves into the life and crucifixion of Jesus Christ, highlighting the religious persecution he faced from the Roman Empire.
-
The Story of the French Huguenots: Set during the tumultuous 16th century in France, this narrative portrays the brutal persecution of Protestants (Huguenots) by the Catholic majority.
-
The Modern Day Story: This segment, set in contemporary America, follows a working-class family struggling against social injustices and economic inequality.
A Visual Feast
“Intolerance” is a visual masterpiece, characterized by Griffith’s masterful use of montage, intercutting, and grand scale sets. The film features some of the most impressive crowd scenes ever captured on celluloid, showcasing thousands of extras in intricately choreographed sequences.
To appreciate the cinematic ingenuity of “Intolerance,” consider these technical marvels:
| Technique | Effect |
|---|---|
| Multi-plane Camera Work | Created illusion of depth and perspective, enhancing epic scope. |
| Cross-cutting | Juxtaposed different narratives, highlighting thematic parallels and creating dramatic tension. |
| Dramatic Lighting | Used to emphasize emotions and symbolic meaning within each story. |
The sheer scale and ambition of the production were groundbreaking for its time. Griffith poured his heart and soul into “Intolerance,” reportedly spending over a year in pre-production and hiring an army of technicians, artists, and extras. The result is a cinematic experience that continues to awe and inspire audiences today.
Beyond the Spectacle: Exploring Themes of Tolerance and Forgiveness
While the technical prowess of “Intolerance” is undeniable, the film’s true power lies in its thematic depth. Griffith uses the interwoven narratives to explore universal themes of intolerance, prejudice, and the cyclical nature of violence. Each story depicts individuals and societies succumbing to their baser instincts, leading to tragic consequences.
The film’s message isn’t simply about condemning intolerance; it also offers a glimmer of hope. Throughout each narrative, acts of compassion, forgiveness, and self-sacrifice emerge. These moments suggest that humanity has the capacity for both great cruelty and remarkable kindness, ultimately leaving audiences to contemplate their own role in fostering a more tolerant world.
A Legacy of Debate and Influence
“Intolerance” is not without its critics. Some argue that Griffith’s handling of certain historical events is inaccurate or insensitive. Others question the film’s melodramatic tone and over-reliance on spectacle. However, even those who find fault with aspects of “Intolerance” acknowledge its undeniable impact on cinema history.
The film’s innovative techniques, ambitious scope, and complex thematic exploration paved the way for future generations of filmmakers. It serves as a reminder of the power of cinema to not only entertain but also to provoke thought, challenge assumptions, and inspire change.
If you are seeking a cinematic experience that is both visually stunning and intellectually engaging, “Intolerance” is a film worth exploring. Be prepared to be swept away by its epic scale and grapple with its enduring message about the human condition.